If I like this kind of music, could you recommend similar bands that I'd like?

I think you would love The Eastern Terminus. I think they're still on an Indie Label, but about half of your music preferences are very similar. The difference is The Eastern Terminus' lyrics; they will hit you hard. That guy's a genius. Check them out on myspace or iTunes or something. You need to hear this. Check out the songs, "London Later," or "Hopeless."